Councillors are advised on 24 November not to defend their refusal of the Barton in Fabis quarry. Consultants say neither reason would stand up at appeal.

Nottinghamshire County Council should not defend its refusal of the Barton in Fabis quarry at next year’s public inquiry, its officers have advised. Councillors on the Planning and Rights of Way Committee will decide on Tuesday 24 November.

The committee refused the sand and gravel quarry in December 2025, against its officers’ recommendation. The applicant, Land Logical Limited, appealed in July.

Independent consultants, Pegasus Group, were then asked how strong the council’s two reasons for refusal were. Their advice is that the council “should not pursue” either of them and “should withdraw” both. (Nottinghamshire County Council, report to Planning and Rights of Way Committee, 24 November 2026)

The site is on land off Green Street at Mill Hill and off Chestnut Lane at Barton in Fabis, about five miles south west of West Bridgford. Our earlier report sets out the scheme and the 1,431 objections.

What the consultants said

The council refused permission for two reasons. Pegasus looked at each.

Reason 1: landscape and need. The refusal said the haul road, the conveyor and its bridge would harm a “highly distinctive landscape”. It also said there was no current need for the sand and gravel. The advice:

  • the harm “would be difficult to substantiate” against the officers’ original report and the applicant’s new landscape assessment
  • the site is allocated for sand and gravel in the county’s Minerals Local Plan, so the applicant does not have to show need
  • the only working quarry in the south of the county, at East Leake, has permission that runs out in 2029
  • the case on need and falling sales “is found to be extremely weak”

Reason 2: environmental protection. The refusal cited flood risk to Holme Pit Site of Special Scientific Interest, the loss of parts of two local wildlife sites, and harm to protected species including barn owls. The advice:

  • Holme Pit is “the only ecological point capable of carrying” the reason on its own, because the applicant has not assessed how much silt could reach it
  • but there is “currently insufficient evidence” that the quarry would harm it
  • the effects on protected species are local and can be dealt with by planning conditions
  • an inspector is unlikely to turn down an allocated site over the loss of about one hectare of county-value habitat

The council also asked JBA Consulting whether more flood and silt modelling would help. The report says that would give “limited useful evidence”, and that protection for the SSSI could be secured through conditions instead.

What the report recommends

The single recommendation is that the council “does not seek to defend its refusal” at the inquiry.

If councillors agree, officers would still take part in the inquiry. They would work on the planning conditions, starting from the 72 drafted for the original committee report. The report says it is important that protections “are not watered down at appeal”.

Councillors could choose instead to defend one or both reasons. The report warns that:

  • neither the council’s planning officers nor Pegasus could then act for the council, under their professional conduct rules
  • councillors themselves would have to give the evidence
  • the council would be at “significant risk” of a “substantial” award of costs

The council has set aside a £500,000 contingency for the appeal. That covers its own costs, the outside advice and a possible costs award.

The quarry is not decided yet

Dropping the defence does not mean the quarry goes ahead. The report says this plainly: a planning inspector will decide the appeal afresh, and can refuse it on different grounds.

Others can still argue against the quarry at the inquiry. The report names:

  • the SAVE (Save the Ancient Valley Environment) campaign group
  • the parish council, which has a legal right to appear
  • the Holme Pit Action Group
  • Rushcliffe Borough Council, which objected to the application

The report adds that objectors would have to persuade the inspector to disagree with the Environment Agency and Natural England, which were both content with the scheme. It calls that “challenging”.

Nottingham City Council’s planning committee voted in September to oppose the part of the site inside the city. Our report on that vote has the detail. The two appeals will be heard together.

Key dates

Date What happens
24 November 2026 County committee decides whether to defend the refusal
18 December 2026 Councils’ statements and statement of common ground due
11 January 2027 Case management conference, by this date
20 April 2027 Evidence and witness statements due
18 May 2027 Inquiry opens at 10am, sitting Tuesdays to Thursdays for up to four weeks

The deadline for comments from the public to the Planning Inspectorate was 17 November, according to the report.

What it means for you

  • If you objected to the application, your comments have already gone to the Planning Inspectorate with personal details removed. The council says it will write again when the inquiry venue and schedule are confirmed, with details of how to attend and speak.
  • Inspectors normally let members of the public speak at an inquiry, the report says.
  • The committee meets at 10.30am on 24 November. The papers, including the four Pegasus advice notes, are on the council’s meeting page. The legal advice is kept private.

Sources